"Workstation" vs. performance PC of same brand / components

  • Follow


Our IT director has ordered a PC to my chosen specs.  This will be a
demo unit to replace my old workstation which has been flaking out
lately and potentially supplied to the rest of the department.

So their supplier (CDW) has offered a computer of the same specs and
brand (HP) except one is in their workstation line and the other is
from their performance PC line.  Being a demo, he chose the non-
workstation option and we can swap later if it's not the right
choice.  I'm not uncomfortable with this, but I know we'll use this
next round of computers for 4+ years and we need dead reliable
equipment.

Aside from a more beefy looking case and maybe better PSU and
motherboard, I'm not sure what else would elevate a PC into a
"workstation".  And I'm not certain that the PSU and mobo are even
significantly better.  The only question I have is related to
expandability for additional RAM and the wattage rating of the PSUs.

For those of you who have faced this decision, what is your opinion?
0
Reply dgeesaman 1/19/2011 12:16:53 AM

On Jan 18, 7:16=A0pm, "dgeesa...@yahooooooo.com" <dgeesa...@gmail.com>
wrote:
> Our IT director has ordered a PC to my chosen specs. =A0This will be a
> demo unit to replace my old workstation which has been flaking out
> lately and potentially supplied to the rest of the department.
>
> So their supplier (CDW) has offered a computer of the same specs and
> brand (HP) except one is in their workstation line and the other is
> from their performance PC line. =A0Being a demo, he chose the non-
> workstation option and we can swap later if it's not the right
> choice. =A0I'm not uncomfortable with this, but I know we'll use this
> next round of computers for 4+ years and we need dead reliable
> equipment.
>
> Aside from a more beefy looking case and maybe better PSU and
> motherboard, I'm not sure what else would elevate a PC into a
> "workstation". =A0And I'm not certain that the PSU and mobo are even
> significantly better. =A0The only question I have is related to
> expandability for additional RAM and the wattage rating of the PSUs.
>
> For those of you who have faced this decision, what is your opinion?

An answer filtered through that explained the cost savings: the non-
workstation was not a full sized motherboard and case.  So not only
are the components of lesser quality the case was too small to fit a
quality graphics card.  And the cost savings was a few hundred bucks
which made no sense.  So if anyone else considers this option don't
bother, get the workstation platform.

There is a workstation computer in the mail now.  :)

David
0
Reply dgeesaman 1/20/2011 12:23:42 AM


1 Replies
211 Views

(page loaded in 0.082 seconds)

Similiar Articles:









7/14/2012 2:53:17 PM


Reply: