COMPGROUPS.NET | Search | Post Question | Groups | Stream | About | Register

### Cutting hole through tube

• Email
• Follow

```I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8" diameter
hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.

I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8" circle
on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in the
middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I get.
I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
through the tube.

Any help is greatly appreciated.

```
 0

See related articles to this posting

```Terry,

Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or on
a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the 1.5"
diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru the
tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are many
different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.

Sincerely,
Jerry Forcier

Terry G wrote:

>I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8" diameter
>hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
>
>I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8" circle
>on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in the
>middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I get.
>I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
>through the tube.
>
>Any help is greatly appreciated.
>
>
>
>

```
 0

```If you drawn the tube centered on the origin/planes. Select one of the other
planes draw a circle and extrude each way to the surface. That way, if you
change your tube dia, the hole still penetrates to the outside.
Regards
Tony O'Hara

"Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
diameter
> hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
>
> I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
circle
> on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in the
> middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I
get.
> I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
> through the tube.
>
> Any help is greatly appreciated.
>
>

```
 0

```I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a very
obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.

I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my tube.
I then used the sweep function to create my tube.

The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the tube is
along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane, either
the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius centered
exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that the
extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this circle on
different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\

When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure what
you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I draw
happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure how to
draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want at that
exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.

Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for the
help.

"Jerry Forcier" <jforcier@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:3MC0c.153456\$jk2.594945@attbi_s53...
> Terry,
>
> Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
> tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or on
> a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the 1.5"
> diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru the
> tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
> they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
> another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are many
> different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
> 'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.
>
> Sincerely,
> Jerry Forcier
>
>
>
>
> Terry G wrote:
>
> >I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
diameter
> >hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
> >
> >I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
circle
> >on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in the
> >middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I
get.
> >I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
> >through the tube.
> >
> >Any help is greatly appreciated.
> >
> >
> >
> >
>

```
 0

```"Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a
> very obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.
>
> I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
> diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
> perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my
> tube.  I then used the sweep function to create my tube.

you could just extrude the first sketch (no real need to sweep a straight
tube).  you can even draw a single circle & do a thin-extrude

> The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the tube
> is along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane,
> either the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius
> centered exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that
> the extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this
> circle on different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\

you're there, not sure why you can't cut.  select the sketch first, then
cut-extrude should become active

> When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure
> what you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I
> draw happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure
> how to draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want
> at that exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.
>
> Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for the
> help.

```
 0

```Maybe the sweep is what's stopping it.  With your first two circles in the
sketch, forget the line and instead of using a sweep, try an extruded boss.
This should work.

WT

"Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a
very
> obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.
>
> I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
> diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
> perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my
tube.
> I then used the sweep function to create my tube.
>
> The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the tube
is
> along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane,
either
> the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius centered
> exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that the
> extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this circle on
> different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\
>
> When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure
what
> you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I draw
> happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure how to
> draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want at
that
> exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.
>
> Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for the
> help.
>
> "Jerry Forcier" <jforcier@comcast.net> wrote in message
> news:3MC0c.153456\$jk2.594945@attbi_s53...
> > Terry,
> >
> > Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
> > tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or on
> > a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the 1.5"
> > diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru the
> > tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
> > they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
> > another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are many
> > different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
> > 'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.
> >
> > Sincerely,
> > Jerry Forcier
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > Terry G wrote:
> >
> > >I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
> diameter
> > >hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
> > >
> > >I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
> circle
> > >on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in
the
> > >middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I
> get.
> > >I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
> > >through the tube.
> > >
> > >Any help is greatly appreciated.
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
>
>

```
 0

```Ok, two things...  and pardon me if I misunderstood something...

1) when you make your tube try the extrude rather than sweep.  you can do it
the way you are but it's the long way around for what you've described.

2) I followed your described steps exactly and it worked as expected.  It
sounds to me like you created your tube using "Insert - Surface - Sweep"
instead of "Insert - Boss/Extrude Sweep".  Go back and double check, I bet
the ends of your tube are open and the space between the inside and outside
walls is empty.  You're looking for a solid and ending up with two surfaces
instead.  Besides that, consider point 1.

- Eddy

"Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a
very
> obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.
>
> I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
> diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
> perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my
tube.
> I then used the sweep function to create my tube.
>
> The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the tube
is
> along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane,
either
> the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius centered
> exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that the
> extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this circle on
> different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\
>
> When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure
what
> you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I draw
> happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure how to
> draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want at
that
> exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.
>
> Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for the
> help.
>
> "Jerry Forcier" <jforcier@comcast.net> wrote in message
> news:3MC0c.153456\$jk2.594945@attbi_s53...
> > Terry,
> >
> > Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
> > tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or on
> > a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the 1.5"
> > diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru the
> > tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
> > they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
> > another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are many
> > different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
> > 'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.
> >
> > Sincerely,
> > Jerry Forcier
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > Terry G wrote:
> >
> > >I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
> diameter
> > >hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
> > >
> > >I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
> circle
> > >on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in
the
> > >middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I
> get.
> > >I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
> > >through the tube.
> > >
> > >Any help is greatly appreciated.
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
>
>

```
 0

```Here's something which might help you or confuse you more??

http://www.zxys.com/swparts/pipe-test-w-holes.zip    (23K)

From what you explain, and if the extrude-cut is greyed out, it sounds
like you maybe using surfaces?

...

Terry G wrote:
>
> I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a very
> obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.
>
> I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
> diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
> perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my tube.
> I then used the sweep function to create my tube.
>
> The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the tube is
> along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane, either
> the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius centered
> exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that the
> extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this circle on
> different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\
>
> When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure what
> you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I draw
> happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure how to
> draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want at that
> exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.
>
> Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for the
> help.
>
> "Jerry Forcier" <jforcier@comcast.net> wrote in message
> news:3MC0c.153456\$jk2.594945@attbi_s53...
> > Terry,
> >
> > Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
> > tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or on
> > a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the 1.5"
> > diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru the
> > tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
> > they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
> > another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are many
> > different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
> > 'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.
> >
> > Sincerely,
> > Jerry Forcier
> >
> >
> >
> >
> > Terry G wrote:
> >
> > >I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
> diameter
> > >hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
> > >
> > >I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
> circle
> > >on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in the
> > >middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I
> get.
> > >I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
> > >through the tube.
> > >
> > >Any help is greatly appreciated.
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> >
```
 0

```It looks as if the sweep function does not allow a cut extrude feature.  I
did create my tube using a revolve boss and extruded boss and the extrude
cut worked perfect.  This bothers me though.  Because the straight tubes are
not a problem now, but I have also designed a tube frame with many odd bends
and angles using the sweep function.  So how would I notch out a hole in the
frame without the extrude-cut feature being available.  I tested this out,
and sure enough, it is not even highlighted when I open my frame.sldprt
file.  Same problem I had when I used the sweep function for my tube.

I wonder what reasons solidworks would have not allowing an extrude-cut
function on a tube that uses the sweep feature?  I thought the sweep feature
was one of the more common ways to design round tube frames.

Thanks for all the help.

"Wayne Tiffany" <wayne.tiffany@asi.com> wrote in message
news:c208bd\$1m2c7f\$1@ID-201804.news.uni-berlin.de...
> Maybe the sweep is what's stopping it.  With your first two circles in the
> sketch, forget the line and instead of using a sweep, try an extruded
boss.
> This should work.
>
>   WT
>
> "Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> > I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a
> very
> > obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.
> >
> > I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
> > diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
> > perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my
> tube.
> > I then used the sweep function to create my tube.
> >
> > The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the
tube
> is
> > along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane,
> either
> > the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius centered
> > exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that the
> > extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this circle
on
> > different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\
> >
> > When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure
> what
> > you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I
draw
> > happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure how
to
> > draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want at
> that
> > exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.
> >
> > Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for
the
> > help.
> >
> > "Jerry Forcier" <jforcier@comcast.net> wrote in message
> > news:3MC0c.153456\$jk2.594945@attbi_s53...
> > > Terry,
> > >
> > > Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
> > > tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or
on
> > > a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the
1.5"
> > > diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru
the
> > > tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
> > > they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
> > > another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are
many
> > > different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
> > > 'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.
> > >
> > > Sincerely,
> > > Jerry Forcier
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > > Terry G wrote:
> > >
> > > >I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
> > diameter
> > > >hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
> > > >
> > > >I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
> > circle
> > > >on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in
> the
> > > >middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as
I
> > get.
> > > >I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my
hole
> > > >through the tube.
> > > >
> > > >Any help is greatly appreciated.
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>

```
 0

```"Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> It looks as if the sweep function does not allow a cut extrude feature.  I
> did create my tube using a revolve boss and extruded boss and the extrude
> cut worked perfect.  This bothers me though.  Because the straight tubes
are
> not a problem now, but I have also designed a tube frame with many odd
bends
> and angles using the sweep function.  So how would I notch out a hole in
the
> frame without the extrude-cut feature being available.  I tested this out,
> and sure enough, it is not even highlighted when I open my frame.sldprt
> file.  Same problem I had when I used the sweep function for my tube.
>
> I wonder what reasons solidworks would have not allowing an extrude-cut
> function on a tube that uses the sweep feature?  I thought the sweep
feature
> was one of the more common ways to design round tube frames.
>
> Thanks for all the help.

cut-extrude works for me using a sweep

```
 0

```Terry,

Without seeing your file, it's not clear what is going on from what you
have stated.
And you've stated so far does not make sense, those functions do and
should work.

You can send the file to me if you want (less than 2 megs, zipped,

...

Terry G wrote:
>
> It looks as if the sweep function does not allow a cut extrude feature.  I
> did create my tube using a revolve boss and extruded boss and the extrude
> cut worked perfect.  This bothers me though.  Because the straight tubes are
> not a problem now, but I have also designed a tube frame with many odd bends
> and angles using the sweep function.  So how would I notch out a hole in the
> frame without the extrude-cut feature being available.  I tested this out,
> and sure enough, it is not even highlighted when I open my frame.sldprt
> file.  Same problem I had when I used the sweep function for my tube.
>
> I wonder what reasons solidworks would have not allowing an extrude-cut
> function on a tube that uses the sweep feature?  I thought the sweep feature
> was one of the more common ways to design round tube frames.
>
> Thanks for all the help.
>
> "Wayne Tiffany" <wayne.tiffany@asi.com> wrote in message
> news:c208bd\$1m2c7f\$1@ID-201804.news.uni-berlin.de...
> > Maybe the sweep is what's stopping it.  With your first two circles in the
> > sketch, forget the line and instead of using a sweep, try an extruded
> boss.
> > This should work.
> >
> >   WT
> >
> > "Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> > > I have tried your exact explanation many times, so I must be missing a
> > very
> > > obvious step.  Here is what I am doing.
> > >
> > > I created two circles in my first sketch, one to determine the outside
> > > diameter and one the inside diameter of my tube.  Then I drew a line
> > > perpendicular to the center of my circle to determine the length of my
> > tube.
> > > I then used the sweep function to create my tube.
> > >
> > > The bottom of my tube is centered at the origin, and the axis of the
> tube
> > is
> > > along the Y axis.  Now I am starting a new sketch, selecting a plane,
> > either
> > > the front or right plane, and drawing a circle with .325 radius centered
> > > exactly 1 inch above the bottom of my tube.  The problem is that the
> > > extrude-cut option is not available.  I have tired creating this circle
> on
> > > different planes and still no extrude-cut option.\
> > >
> > > When you said not to make my circle directly on the tube, I'm not sure
> > what
> > > you mean.  When I start my sketch, I select a plane, and the circle I
> draw
> > > happens to fall right inside the middle of the tube.  I'm not sure how
> to
> > > draw the circle away from the tube and still achieve the cut I want at
> > that
> > > exact location.  Maybe this is my problem.
> > >
> > > Like I said, I am probably overlooking something obvious.   Thanks for
> the
> > > help.
> > >
> > > "Jerry Forcier" <jforcier@comcast.net> wrote in message
> > > news:3MC0c.153456\$jk2.594945@attbi_s53...
> > > > Terry,
> > > >
> > > > Make the sketch of the hole you want on a plane, not directly on the
> > > > tube.  The plane can be one of the main planes that already exist or
> on
> > > > a new plane that you construct.  Then just extrude-cut through the
> 1.5"
> > > > diameter tube.  Make sure that the sketch of the hole will pass thru
> the
> > > > tube.  Usually, sketches are extruded 'normal' to the plane upon which
> > > > they are created, but in 2004 one can extrude at an angle by following
> > > > another sketched direction, shown on yet another plane.   There are
> many
> > > > different terminations to the extrude-cut - the simplest is probably
> > > > 'through-all', pointing in the direction towards the tube.
> > > >
> > > > Sincerely,
> > > > Jerry Forcier
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Terry G wrote:
> > > >
> > > > >I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
> > > diameter
> > > > >hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
> > > > >
> > > > >I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
> > > circle
> > > > >on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in
> > the
> > > > >middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as
> I
> > > get.
> > > > >I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my
> hole
> > > > >through the tube.
> > > > >
> > > > >Any help is greatly appreciated.
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
```
 0

```Problem solved thanks to everyone's help.

I was using the Insert - Surface - Sweep.   I deleted that feature on my
tubes and frame and used the sweep boss/base feature, and the extrude cut
works perfect.  I don't know why I chose the surface sweep.  Still learning!

I am amazed out how quickly I received responses.  Thanks again to everyone.
What a great group.

"Terry G" <terry.gaston@cox.net> wrote in message
> I am having a difficult time figuring out how to cut a simple 5/8"
diameter
> hole through a 1.5" diameter tube.
>
> I have drawn my tube using the sweep feature.  I then sketched a 5/8"
circle
> on the tube where i want the hole. I have tried placing the circle in the
> middle of the tube and on the surface of the tube.  This is as far as I
get.
> I can not seem to figure out how to extrude this circle to cut my hole
> through the tube.
>
> Any help is greatly appreciated.
>
>

```
 0