Solidworks & Radeon video cards

Does any body have any experiences, good or bad with Radeon gameing cards
such as the 9600 & 9800 pro.
I can get either of these cards fairly cheaply for a new computer i
am building and want a card that will do most things well enough.I dont
really want a specialist cad card.
The Solidworks site gives these cards a "red mark"  useing winxp but doesnt
really say
if they are seriously bad for SW,or have just minor annoyance issues.
Thanks in advance.


0
Robert
12/14/2003 1:50:57 AM
comp.cad.solidworks 14465 articles. 56 followers. Post Follow

6 Replies
351 Views

Similar Articles

[PageSpeed] 38
"Robert R" <rrtk@clear.net> wrote in message
news:WlPCb.12863$ws.1247705@news02.tsnz.net...
> Does any body have any experiences, good or bad with Radeon gameing cards
> such as the 9600 & 9800 pro.
> I can get either of these cards fairly cheaply for a new computer i
> am building and want a card that will do most things well enough.I dont
> really want a specialist cad card.
> The Solidworks site gives these cards a "red mark"  useing winxp but
doesnt
> really say
> if they are seriously bad for SW,or have just minor annoyance issues.
> Thanks in advance.
>
>

Red means serious problems, don't use these cards.

Richard


0
Richard
12/14/2003 2:03:50 AM
On Sun, 14 Dec 2003 14:50:57 +1300, "Robert R" <rrtk@clear.net> wrote:

>Does any body have any experiences, good or bad with Radeon gameing cards
>such as the 9600 & 9800 pro.
>I can get either of these cards fairly cheaply for a new computer i
>am building and want a card that will do most things well enough.I dont
>really want a specialist cad card.
>The Solidworks site gives these cards a "red mark"  useing winxp but doesnt
>really say
>if they are seriously bad for SW,or have just minor annoyance issues.
>Thanks in advance.
>

Hi,

I had a Radeon 9800 Pro 128meg, and had nothing but problems
in Solidworks, for all other multimedia and games that card was
exceptional, but when using "real" OpenGL application nothing
would work right, I got myself a Leadtek GeForce FX5900 256mb
all was pretty good when I installed it, but now with RivaTuner I have
a Quadro FX3000.. and this rocks..

Regards,

Louis.


0
Louis
12/14/2003 7:15:49 PM
I am using the beta CAT3.10 drivers released to fix some issues with the
Call of Duty game at home on my Radeon 9600pro and the disappearing
dimensions are gone.  That was my main issue with the old drivers.  Looks
like there still my be a limit on how many windows you can have open but I
have that problem at work too sometimes with a FireGL card (older 8700 so
different chipset)  It does seem as if the Nvidia cards are the way to go
for Solidworks at the time being.  New workstations at work will be Quadro
based instead of FireGL cards.

Don
"Robert R" <rrtk@clear.net> wrote in message
news:WlPCb.12863$ws.1247705@news02.tsnz.net...
> Does any body have any experiences, good or bad with Radeon gameing cards
> such as the 9600 & 9800 pro.
> I can get either of these cards fairly cheaply for a new computer i
> am building and want a card that will do most things well enough.I dont
> really want a specialist cad card.
> The Solidworks site gives these cards a "red mark"  useing winxp but
doesnt
> really say
> if they are seriously bad for SW,or have just minor annoyance issues.
> Thanks in advance.
>
>


0
Don
12/14/2003 11:52:25 PM
Robert,

For a few years I've been reading all these wonderful reviews about these
ATI (Radeon's and Fire) cards versus Nvidia and others.  The normal
experience that myself and a number of my friends that use SolidWorks is
that these cards just don't work well with SolidWorks.  Slow performance, to
many minor annoyances, and so on.  To me it seems like the drivers are never
quite right. I would suggest that these cards be used for graphics apps,
multimedia and games.  Nvidia Quadro 4' XGL series and Quadro FX's seem to
be the way to go.  I personally think the Quadro FX500, FX1000, and FX2000
are as good as it gets for SolidWorks. In addition now they have recently
added the FX1100 and the FX3000 to the FX line.

Adding one of the above Nvidia cards to a motherboard that has an AMD
processor (Athlon or 64) and the Nvidia nforce motherboard chipset is I
think a very good overall system.


"Robert R" <rrtk@clear.net> wrote in message
news:WlPCb.12863$ws.1247705@news02.tsnz.net...
> Does any body have any experiences, good or bad with Radeon gameing cards
> such as the 9600 & 9800 pro.
> I can get either of these cards fairly cheaply for a new computer i
> am building and want a card that will do most things well enough.I dont
> really want a specialist cad card.
> The Solidworks site gives these cards a "red mark"  useing winxp but
doesnt
> really say
> if they are seriously bad for SW,or have just minor annoyance issues.
> Thanks in advance.
>
>


0
Dave
12/15/2003 12:36:04 AM
i have a duel monitor system at work. a 3dlabs card apg and a radeon
pci. my radeon will not work with solidwork. not even if i set it as
my main graphics card.


Louis Raymond <goglu312@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:<7idptv00d24gjkd4c66heddm919nhh84u5@4ax.com>...
> On Sun, 14 Dec 2003 14:50:57 +1300, "Robert R" <rrtk@clear.net> wrote:
> 
> >Does any body have any experiences, good or bad with Radeon gameing cards
> >such as the 9600 & 9800 pro.
> >I can get either of these cards fairly cheaply for a new computer i
> >am building and want a card that will do most things well enough.I dont
> >really want a specialist cad card.
> >The Solidworks site gives these cards a "red mark"  useing winxp but doesnt
> >really say
> >if they are seriously bad for SW,or have just minor annoyance issues.
> >Thanks in advance.
> >
> 
> Hi,
> 
> I had a Radeon 9800 Pro 128meg, and had nothing but problems
> in Solidworks, for all other multimedia and games that card was
> exceptional, but when using "real" OpenGL application nothing
> would work right, I got myself a Leadtek GeForce FX5900 256mb
> all was pretty good when I installed it, but now with RivaTuner I have
> a Quadro FX3000.. and this rocks..
> 
> Regards,
> 
> Louis.
0
sldprt
12/15/2003 3:13:08 AM
Thanks for the input guys looks like i will be going with Invidia.


Robert


0
Robert
12/15/2003 5:47:30 AM
Reply:
Similar Artilces:

[News] Intel Video Benchmarks on Linux
Intel GMA950 & xf86-video-intel 2.1.0 ,----[ Quote ] | While we had not included benchmarks in this article from previous | xf86-video-intel driver releases, we haven't found any noticeable performance | improvements in any configuration when using version 2.1.0 compared to the | previous 2.0 release that had come out two months ago. `---- http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=774&num=1 Graphs on page, derived from FPS in high-end Linux games. ...

SolidWorks or ProE?
Hello group, this topic may have been posted before but my firm is looking to either get SolidWorks or ProE to do our design work. Our main work is machine design which consist of 1000 parts or more. Can anyone give any advice on which would be the best for us? Thanks in advance Eric Solidworks "CDC" <ecope@highland.net> wrote in message news:dgd80h$efio$1@news3.infoave.net... > Hello group, this topic may have been posted before but my firm is looking > to either get SolidWorks or ProE to do our design work. > > Our main work is machine design which consist...

Add Vcapg2 .dll video in gui axes
ow yo implement vcapg2.dll video in gui axes? I use : cardnum=vcapg2(1);% you will get available video capture devices number usually 1 set(1,'doublebuffer','on'); aa=vcapg2; axes(handles.video); imshow(aa); But it capture the image and stuck at there..not video image ...

scsi card reader
Has anyone had success with a Microtech PCD 47B triple card reader? I know some people have tried scsi card readers in the past, and some of them worked. Also what version of HD driver is best for this type of thing? Thanks, Mark in article 1117134838.849496.280070@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com, fried.man@sympatico.ca wrote on 5/26/2005 3:13 PM: > Has anyone had success with a Microtech PCD 47B triple card reader? > I know some people have tried scsi card readers in the past, and some > of them worked. Also what version of HD driver is best for this type of > thing? ...

The Best SolidWorks Workstation
What are your opinions on the best SW workstation for very complex parts? Pretend money is no object. I'm looking for something that SW can utilize. Not a 4 core workstation that SW can only utilize at 25%. Off the shelf would be fine, custom built would be fine as well. Thanks in advance! If you do not want a four core workstation, then you do not want the best system that is out today for SolidWorks. The new Core i7 and Xeon Nehalem core cpu's are the fastest for SW. They are four core processors with hyper-threading. Head over to the forums at SolidWorks and search the Performa...

Cheaper ATI Radeon Cards from Island
We are now providing our own branded ATI Radeon 64MB PCI Cards We also provide the driver installation CD to run with OpenVMS 7.3> Part Number IC-PBXGG-RA Price per unit is $179 Buy online at https://icusc.com -- David B Turner ============================================= Island Computers US Corp PO Box 86 Tybee GA 31328 Toll Free: 1-877 636 4332 x201, Mobile x251 Email: dturner@islandco.com International & Local: (001)- 404-806-7749 Fax: 912 786 8505 Web: www.islandco.com ============================================= ...

Converting video from wmv to mp4
I have been using MPEG Streamclip (MS) to convert wmv files to mp4's. I drag the wmv file into the MS window, then select "Export to MPEG-4". I then see another window, in addition to the main video window, where I can choose various options: Compression: I leave this set at H.264. Quality: Well, I set it at 100%. Why not? More quality is better isn't it? (Frankly I'm not sure what this one is all about.) Limit Data Rate: I usually try to match the Mbps rate of the original wmv file. I leave the other settings alone. The mp4's I get out of thi...

SmarTeam - SolidWorks
Nowadays I am working with SmarTeam 4. We are going to migrate to V5R12. In old system I create 3D drawing creating Document link on 3D Part or Assembly. In new version I noticed difference. SmarTeam create new type of link SolidWorks links and the old way of my working create double link, one Document and second SolidWorks. Anyone can tel me how should I work in SmarTeam V5. Artur ...

Print 100 solidworks drawings to pdf using program
Is there a way to program solidworks to print out all the drawings in the folder in PDF format. Otherwise I will have to end up doing it manually. Can anyone please advise? Thanks SW task scheduler should do what you are after. -- Brian Hokanson Starting Line Products Thank you Brian, The solution works. Fantastic. Thanks a ton. Brian wrote: > SW task scheduler should do what you are after. > -- > Brian Hokanson > Starting Line Products Hello, I found that SW task scheduler works extremely slow. How long did it take to convert the 100 drawings. Elmo venurg@gmail.com ...

SolidWorks Student vs. SolidWorks Pro.
Hi, I am going to study Mechanical Engineering next year in Germany. Now I want to use this time meaningfully and starts learn to use Solid Works. I have the decision between Solid Works student (91?) and professional (a lot of more money). Have I all important functions in the study-version (tutorial, eDrawing, etc)? Thank you, Daniel Hemmerling, Cologne Germany P.S. Found right writing errors may be kept Hello towarts you Daniel, Get for youself the version for the student if you only are for to learn. For paying too much to simple learn, the profesion version you are ...

Higher resolution video card for UMAX S900
Does anyone know of a higher resolution video card that would work in a UMAX S900 that would result in something roughly near a 1400 x 900 resolution for a widescreen Viewsonic LCD display? Gerry In article <110720060124499497%gconettaDONTSPAM@gmail.com>, G.E.R.R.Y. <gconettaDONTSPAM@gmail.com> wrote: > Does anyone know of a higher resolution video card that would work in a > UMAX S900 that would result in something roughly near a 1400 x 900 > resolution for a widescreen Viewsonic LCD display? > > Gerry I've been told that Sonnet or Radeon 9200 PCI cards wil...

Cross-platform video chat
My daughter has the world's cutest toddlers and a PC. I, grand-dad, live 300 miles away and have a MacBook Pro with the built-in camera. So you now understand my subject topic! I'm new to the video chat stuff, so I'd appreciate help with what she could use and I could use and us both see/hear each other. (She mentioned that She has Skype, but Skype's Mac version does not yet support video.) I'm thinking that I can't use iChat for this, but if I'm wrong let me know. Thanks, Richard Sent using the Microsoft Entourage 2004 for Mac Test Drive. Richard Huggins <h...

Xilinx dev board with high quality video?
I'm doing a proof of concept that requires high quality video out. Either RGB or composite is fine (both would be great). Spartan III or V4 preferred, with add-on modules OK. The ML401 is a great board, and great value, but the rgb output just sucks. Anyone got any recommendations? Thanks "Pete Fraser" <pfraser@covad.net> schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:11jqt4dj0bhh71b@news.supernews.com... > I'm doing a proof of concept that requires high quality video out. > Either RGB or composite is fine (both would be great). > > Spartan III or V4 preferred, with ad...

Solidworks 2005 SP
Anyone know where to get it or can supply a valid S/N to th solidworks website? From the valid software package you purchased from your valid SolidWorks reseller. Best Regards, Devon T. Sowell www.3-ddesignsolutions.com "Darin" <dcyns@adelphia.net> wrote in message news:kMadnTM9iZpiuBvfRVn-2g@adelphia.com... > Anyone know where to get it or can supply a valid S/N to th solidworks > website? > > We purchased SW2005, and our support has run out. Just needed Sp3. Any help would be appreciated. "Devon T. Sowell" <dtsowell@3-ddesignsolutions.com>...

Laptop EVO N610 s-video outpu problem
hi, I have an EVO N610 Laptop connected to my tv using s-video connection. Everything is fine but when playing videos media players do not pass video signal to output. (tried out WMP and DIVX) I guess it might be sort of hardware problem or this functionality is deliberately disabled. I thought the s-video output is there to connect the laptop to tv and watch it..... Is there any way around? Cheers Dusan Do you mean the line ausio out is disabled? Al S "Dusan" <a@a> wrote in message news:3f5f6d42_2@mk-nntp-2.news.uk.tiscali.com... > hi, > I have an EVO N610 Laptop co...

New Vulcan.NET Video
Hello All, GrafX Software is pleased to present a new video titled "Using Vulcan.Net's Transporter". If you have MS media player installed on your machine, this is by far the easiest way to learn what's new with Vulcan.NET. Click here to view. http://www.govulcan.net/portal/Video/tabid/60/Default.aspx and Click on "Using Vulcan.NET's Transporter" Play video. "Using Vulcan.NET transporter" shows you how you can transport your Visual Objects application to Vulcan.NET. The video uses our download-able sample project "Orders" w...

VoicePulse Plans Video Phone Service
http://www.prnewswire.com/cgi-bin/stories.pl?ACCT=109&STORY=/www/story/12-08-2004/0002590652&EDATE= http://www.voicepulse.com Company to offer video service using award-winning network JAMESBURG, N.J., Dec. 8 /PRNewswire/ -- VoicePulse Inc. today announced plans to enhance the consumer's telephone experience by incorporating videophone service into their existing Voice-over-IP service in the second half of 2005. With the recent widespread use of camera and video-enhanced mobile phones, company executives believe videophones in the home are the next logical step...

Is there any way to use the UDP VIs with multiple network cards?
I am trying to send UDP traffic from point A to point B, and would like to be able to do this using multiple network cards on a single computer rather than having to use more than one computer. Is there a way to specify which network card is the sending card using the UDP VIs if more than one card is present in a PC? I'm not sure I understand your problem and why you would need more than one computer to send traffic. If your sender is supposed to write to a specific IP, then you specify just that IP for UDP write and the OS will choose the NIC card that's on the same subnet. You can ...

Dual head graphic cards for Linux
I've tried a Matrox G400 under XFree 4.2.1.1 with the beta driver available on matrox web site. The dualhead works but so bad that it's not usable. Does anybody experienced a dualhead graphics card well supported by linux (with stable drivers) ? thanks Xavier On Thu, 04 Dec 2003 22:29:15 +0100, xavier wrote: > Does anybody experienced a dualhead graphics card well supported by > > linux (with stable drivers) ? If you don't mind using closed source drivers, then I recommend nvidia cards. I run a GeForce 4 TI4200 using nvidia's drivers and in runs my two mon...

Who Has The Best And Most Creative SolidWorks Blog?
What SolidWorks blog is attracting far more than just SolidWorks loyalists with their head up shoved up their ass? What SolidWorks blog has become the leader in most people posting to it? What SolidWorks blog is the most creative? I wish I could say SolidMentor but Ben Eadie seems to have gotten side tracked. Hope he's okay and just very busy with work. In the mean time the winner by a mile is SolidSmack. www.solidsmack.com Has the owner of Solidsmack used the word "pimpin" yet? If not, I think it=92s time "pimpin" made its debut on SolidSmack. Are you posting t...

Palm video
Palm is dead. It took me 4 hours of research to realize there is no good free video player for the Palm. Even with OS 5x. The Pocket PC rules and good bye Palm. In article <1103314988.423932.195370@f14g2000cwb.googlegroups.com>, timisme@yahoo.com wrote: <blah> Troll. timisme@yahoo.com wrote: > Palm is dead. It took me 4 hours of research to realize there is no > good free video player for the Palm. Even with OS 5x. The Pocket PC > rules and good bye Palm. Interestingly, there is an effort just now getting underway to start a free video player, simil...

======> Secret Video CLIPS <=========
Watch the Free ==Videos== of All --->LESBIAN College Girl<--- Having Horny VIDEOS...... Here the Huge Collection of Horny Lesbian College Girl & More of School Girls SECRET MMS CLIPStoo... Watch the Free Video Here that will make you satisfied at all.... www.googlemobilesphones.blogspot.com www.secretwebcams.blogspot.com www.netmoney2you.blogspot.com ...

Video Studio 7 SVCD disc image
If one creates a disc image file in the create disk area, how do you make use of the file created? I have Nero 5.5 and it didn't like the file with the ixa extension when I tried to burn it as a video disk. Ron You must have a program named "Disc Image Recorder" or maybe just "Burn Disc" which normally is included in - and installed together with - your package Studio 7. Hans "Ron" <newdoverman@yahoo.ca> schreef in bericht news:bv9mck$q415h$1@ID-218537.news.uni-berlin.de... > If one creates a disc image file in the create disk are...

WATCH WORLD`S MOST FUNNIEST PRANK VIDEOS EVER.
WATCH WORLD`S MOST BEAUTIFUL PLACES. http://wallpapers-stocks.blogspot.com/ http://wallpapers-stocks.blogspot.com/ http://wallpapers-stocks.blogspot.com/ http://wallpapers-stocks.blogspot.com/ WATCH WORLD`S MOST HILARIOUS FUNNIEST VIDEOS. http://funnyvideos-2011.blogspot.com/ http://funnyvideos-2011.blogspot.com/ http://funnyvideos-2011.blogspot.com/ http://funnyvideos-2011.blogspot.com/ ...

changing video card question
Hi, When installing a new video card, at what point does one disable the previous video cards configuration? Is it procedure, to just replace the old adapter, boot up, and then install drivers? Please, advise. Thank you. On Wed, 03 May 2006 14:40:56 -0400, Joe <Joe@invalid.con> wrote: >Hi, > >When installing a new video card, at what point does one disable the >previous video cards configuration? Is it procedure, to just replace >the old adapter, boot up, and then install drivers? Please, advise. >Thank you. > I don't know about Win XP, but in Win95/98 ...